Eating Vegan at Elkhart Lake, Wisconsin

Elkhart Lake is that rare place, a tiny and charming Midwest town where a vegan will find plenty to eat. An hour north of Milwaukee, with a population of 965, Elkhart Lake has a long history as a resort town. I spent a few days there in late summer and fell in love with the lake and the town’s pretty Victorian buildings.

Elkhart Lake sunset

Sunset over Elkhart Lake.

Ostoff Resort

I stayed at the Osthoff Resort. It originally opened in 1886 and remained a popular resort hotel until the 1950s. Then the property operated as a performing arts-themed summer camp for 30 years. In 1995, it reverted to its roots. After a major facelift, it reopened for business as a Victorianish, all-suite hotel.

The Osthoff has two restaurant – Otto’s, its casual place, and Lola’s on the Lake, a fine dining restaurant. My first night in town, I ate at Otto’s. Being far from my gourmet home of Portland, Oregon, I braced myself for iceberg lettuce. But no. Otto’s delivered a glorious salad full of fresh and healthy greens. I later learned that much of the Osthoff’s produce is grown in its own garden.

Ottos Osthoff Elkhart Lake

Great greens at Otto’s, the Osthoff’s casual restaurant.

I was lucky to be invited on a small tour of the Osthoff organic gardens, guided by Lola Roeh, the resort’s general manager. She explained how back in 2009, she started worrying about feeding her guests GMOs and other possibly icky substances. “We knew we could control this food for our guests,” she said, showing us the original patch of ground.

They started with 2,000 square feet of herbs, rhubarb, tomatoes and peppers. Soon they added 300 asparagus plants, then chamomile and lavender to use in their delightful Aspira Spa. The garden grew and grew, until now there are small satellite gardens near the restaurants, herbs outside the resort’s cooking school, and even rows of spearmint outside the bar for mojitos.

Mark Roehrig, the grounds manager, is philosophical about organic gardening. Since you can’t fight nature unarmed, it involves a lot of acceptance. He remembers one sad morning: “Our four-legged friends came in and nibbled everything down. We came back in after a weekend and all that was left were stalks.” Still, plenty of food survives. Their most recent garlic harvest yielded 100 pounds. Last fall they reaped 3,000 pounds of butternut squash.

Osthoff organic garden

Radishes, straight from the ground.

I got to benefit from this bounty on my last night in Elkhart Lake, at Lola on the Lake’s farm dinner. The tablescape was so lush with greenery, I expected a squirrel to pop out. We feasted on intricate creations. I sat with the one other vegan at the dinner. We marveled at the ingenuity of each dish, especially a salad topped with frozen tomato granita.

Osthoff farm dinner Elkhart Lake

One impressive tablescape at the Osthoff’s farm dinner.

Osthoff farm dinner

Vegetable artwork at the Osthoff farm dinner.

Other Places for Vegan Meals

With its own organic garden, the Osthoff was impressive. But everywhere I went, I found something vegan to eat, and often something pretty good. A few highlights:

The Victorian Village’s Back Porch Bistro made me an excellent Portobello sandwich with the best sautéed spinach I’ve had in a long while. Victorian Village is also a good spot for beach recreation. On their private beach, I rented a stand up paddle board, and had a lovely afternoon paddling around the lake.

Victorian village back porch bistro elkhart lake

This spinach was really good.

The Paddock Club is a super happening restaurant on Elkhart’s main strip. It packs in customers for Tuesday’s small plates night. Three or four of the plates were easily converted to vegan, including a veggie coconut curry.

Paddock Club Elkhart Lake

Tuesday is small plates night at the Paddock Club.

The Stop-Inn Tavern at Siebkens Resort offers a couple of hearty vegan appetizers. I got the hummus and vegetable plate and some decadently puffy homemade tortilla chips and guacamole.

Stop-Inn Tavern Elkhart Lake

Appetizers at the Stop-Inn Tavern.

The Quit Qui Oc Golf Club restaurant gamely made me a Portobello quesadilla without cheese. And Off the Rail, a darling train-themed café, brewed a fine soy cappuccino.

Off the Rail Elkhart Lake

Off the Rail for soy cappuccino.

The food was good and vegan-friendly in Elkhart Lake. I got plenty of fuel for lake activities, which are the real draw here.

Elkhart Lake kayaking

Fuel up, then back to the lake.

If you like this post, please share!

Leave a Reply